Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Collaboration Tools: The Decision

As you can see, I had a lot of material to review. I did my best to cover each of the criteria and how they applied to the collaboration tools.

Here's a reminder of the results:
  • Hyperoffice - B
  • Vyew - B
  • KeepandShare - C+
  • Project2Manage - C
Based on my grades it came down to Hyperoffice and Vyew. 

I decided that Vyew is a lot more value for my purposes. It is FREE. It has almost all of the same features as the more expensive, Hyperoffice. It is simple, cohesive, user-friendly and very easy for members to collaborate. Compared to the other collaboration tools, I felt it was more intuitive and fun to use.

In case you didn't feel like reading my posts, here is a simple table which demonstrates how each tool met (or fell short of) the criteria:


HyperOffice
Vyew
KeepandShare
Project2Manage
Software/
Hardware Required

No software or hardware requirements.

Hyperdrive installation required for easy uploading—not needed.
No software or hardware requirements.
No software or hardware requirements.
No software or hardware requirements
OS Compatibility
Any Mac or Windows OS.

Any internet browser.
Any Mac or Windows OS.

Any internet browser.
Any Mac or Windows OS.

Any internet browser.
Any Mac or Windows OS.

Any internet browser.
Number of Users
Varies with price
Free account: up to 10 people/room

Upgraded account: up to 80 people/room ($1/additional person 11-80).
Unlimited
Unlimited
Storage Space
1.25GB
No limit to size.
300 “pages” (items) per room.
100MB total.
10MB/upload.

Can be upgraded: 3GB total.
1GB/upload.
150MB
Synchronization and Email
Can be synced with Microsoft Outlook.

Free email with customizable domain.
Your choice of synchronous or asynchronous collaboration.

No email feature or synch with email providers.
No email feature
No email feature, but a message feature exists for communicating with project members.

All edits are up-to-the minute.
Security
Daily virus updates, spam-free
Only upgraded accounts have security.
Only upgraded accounts have security.
Only upgraded accounts have security.

And here is a table with the grade breakdown:

Hyperoffice
Vyew
KeepandShare
Project2Manage
Hardware/Software
Os/Browser
A
A
A
A
Number of Users per Project
C
B
A
A
Storage Space
B
A
D
D
Synchronization/
Email
B
A
D
D
Security
A
C
C
D

I hope that this will help you when selecting a collaboration tool for your needs. If you have further comments or questions, please leave a comment and I will respond promptly!

No comments:

Post a Comment